| Year | Artist | Album |
|---|---|---|
| 2025 | Charmer | Downpour |
| 2024 | Macseal | Permanent Vacation |
| 2023 | Origami Angel | Brightest Days |
| 2022 | Carly Cosgrove | See You In Chemistry |
| 2021 | Sincere Engineer | Bless My Psyche |
| 2020 | Hot Mulligan | You'll Be Fine |
| 2019 | Free Throw | What's Past Is Prologue |
| 2018 | Hippo Campus | Bambi |
| 2017 | Nervous Dater | Don't Be A Stranger |
| 2016 | The Lumineers | Cleopatra |
| 2015 | Turnover | Peripheral Vision |
| 2014 | The Hotelier | Home, Like No Place Is There |
| 2013 | Modern Baseball | You're Gonna Miss It All |
| 2012 | Pentimento | Pentimento |